Topic — Social Security

The break-even calculator is asking the wrong question.

When do I begin withdrawing Social Security retirement benefits?

You can claim as early as 62 or as late as 70, and the difference compounds for the rest of your life. Most advice runs a break-even calculation and a bet on your own death date. That's not a plan. It's a guess dressed up as math.

  • See why break-even math is the wrong frame — and what economics uses instead.
  • Understand how claiming age interacts with retirement timing, taxes, and your spouse's record.
  • Follow a the Lovejoy household through the retire-and-claim decision, dollar for dollar.
  • Learn when delaying isn't actually the right answer.

Watch the overview

A quick look at the claiming decision and why break-even math misleads. Then decide whether this topic is for you.

What you'll learn

This topic is built around one question that matters more than almost any other in retirement planning — and the economics-based answer to it.

Why break-even math is the wrong question

Break-even calculators turn claiming into a bet on your death date. You'll see why economics treats delayed claiming as longevity insurance instead — priced better than anything a private insurer sells.

The rules of the road

Full retirement age, actuarial reductions, delayed retirement credits, and the inflation-indexing that protects your higher benefit from rising prices — the mechanics you need before the decision makes sense.

A household's claiming decision, dollar for dollar

Follow the Lovejoys through the retire-and-claim decision — what five extra years of work is worth, and how much of that gain comes specifically from the claiming age itself.

When delaying isn't the right answer

Health and longevity, the bridge problem, and the couples' claiming pattern — three situations where claiming early is genuinely the better economics, and how to recognize them in your own household.

How to set up MaxiFi to answer this for yourself

A step-by-step walkthrough for entering your earnings record and comparing claiming ages by their effect on your lifetime living standard.

Included with this topic

A free 1:1 session with Professor Puelz — for students who complete the topic

Finish the course and score 7 or higher on the closing quiz, and you unlock a free 15-minute live Zoom session with Professor Robert Puelz — focused entirely on your Social Security claiming question and situation.

This is not a webinar or a group call. It is a 1:1.

Scheduling is simple: after you pass, a form appears inside the course. Fill in a few good times and a sentence about what you want to discuss, and your request goes straight to the Moneygimme team.

Unlock this topic

This is a standalone topic — you don't need to have completed Path 1 or Path 2 first. If you've been wrestling with the claiming-age question, start here.

You'll get the full lesson sequence, the claiming-age framework, the closing quiz, and — after you pass — the chance to schedule a 1:1 Zoom session with Professor Puelz to talk through your own situation.

Price: One-time purchase of $99 for full access.

Unlock for $99 →

After purchase, you'll receive access instructions by email.

Already paid but don't have access? Enter your access code →

Already paid? Enter your access code

If you purchased this topic but weren't taken straight into the course, enter the email you used at checkout and we'll send you a one-time access code.

From Professor Puelz

Keep learning — one insight a week, directly in your inbox.

The newsletter at robertpuelz.substack.com takes the same economics-based thinking behind this topic and applies it to the decisions households face every week. No hot tips. No financial entertainment. Just the stuff that actually moves the needle.

📋
The Briefing

A monthly live session — ask questions, get answers, think out loud with other subscribers.

✉️
Your Questions

Submit your questions directly before each Briefing — paid subscribers move to the front of the line.

💡
The Edge

One financial insight per month that most people never learn — delivered only to paid subscribers.

Moneygimme reader offer

20% off the annual paid rate

$199/year  $159/year — locked in for as long as you stay subscribed.

Subscribe for $159/year → Browse free posts first